How many of you guessed our Florida dessert for this week? I mean it was probably one of our easiest choices yet, with the only surprise coming from how easy it was to make. Are you ready….of course you’re ready – Key Lime Pie!
We adapted this recipe from Cooking Light simply because when you consume this many desserts in one week you have no other choice. We also chose an almond pie crust in place of the graham cracker crust thanks to some of the kitchen tips Mandy posted over at The Complete Cook Book. It turns out the almond pie crust is much healthier than the graham cracker crust, and it holds up better at cold temperatures. Thanks for the tips Mandy!
The almond crust was simple. We combined almond meal, sugar and melted butter. 
We then pressed it down into our 9″ pie pan and baked the crust for 10 minutes at 350F. 
We let the pie crust cool completely before preparing the Key lime filling, which was also super easy. We beat together 2 eggs, 2 egg whites, fat-free sweetened condensed milk, key lime juice and the zest of a lime. 
The custard is then poured over the prepared almond crust and voila! You have a Key lime pie. 
The pie bakes for 20 minutes at 350F and is then cooled and chilled for a minimum of three hours. After that it’s ready for the whip cream topping. 
You can cover the whole pie with whipped cream or just take it around the sides. We opted to take it around the sides and serve it with a slice of lime. 
This pie was a definite success. Dad and Miss A both gave it a solid 4 spoons. Mr. N and I gave it 3 spoons. It’s rich, fresh and delicious! And did I mention how easy this was?! The kids both loved the pie, taking theirs with some extra whipped topping. 
Mr. N had a beard, but with the humidity it quickly began to melt. Don’t worry, he still managed to get it all. 
It’s fair to say that this pie won’t last long in our house. I actually tried to just eat one bite tonight, but before I knew it my entire slice was gone. It’s a keeper. 
Print this recipe: Key Lime Pie with Almond Crust
Eat, Play, Love 
Yumm that looks delish!! and a really great tip for the almond meal crust! Had I known you were “in” Florida, I would have invited you over- you bring the pie and I’ll pour the lemonade!!
LikeLike
Oooh – your blueberry and basil vodka lemonade? I’m in. Yum! 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you so much for the mention! Loved the pics of your little ones.
🙂 Mandy
LikeLike
Thank you for the tips Mandy! I learned a lot. 🙂
LikeLike
Oh, this pie looks sooo delicious! I feel like I’m right in there with Mr. N & Miss A! I like the way you did your cream on the border – looks so yummy yet not overdone. Aren’t Bob’s Red Mill cereals a great discovery? So many varieties with a fabulous range of whole grains.
LikeLike
I love Bob’s Red Mill! I can’t believe how many varieties there are…I have so many more to try. 🙂 I kept my cream on the border for this pie, but the kids loaded up on the whipped topping. LOL. They had fun with it though.
LikeLike
My husband just requested a key lime pie – and I love your almond crust. Perfect timing!
LikeLike
Oh how fun! I hope you enjoy it. I loved that it was so easy to make and it’s still holding up well in the fridge with the leftovers too. (We had a birthday party here yesterday, otherwise I don’t think we’d still have leftovers. LOL!)
LikeLike
You know when they’re licking it off their hands and faces, that you’ve got a winner! Key lime is my Dad’s favourite… I haven’t had it in years! I feel like I should break out the recipe for his birthday this year.
LikeLike
LOL! So true. They never seem to get the “icky” stuff all over themselves. LOL. I’m sure your dad would love it if you made that. Go for it! 🙂
LikeLike
Your pie looks so refreshing, creamy and yummy! I can’t wait to try that pie crust!
LikeLike
Thanks Geni! The pie crust was the easiest I’ve ever made. It was done in 5 minutes. 🙂 Loved it!
LikeLike
Oh so cute the little kids! Very funny pictures ! and of course nice dessert!
goodbye!
LikeLike
Thanks! The kids had a lot of fun with the whipped topping. Actually we all did. LOL! Thanks for visiting and commenting. 🙂
LikeLike
What a delicious dessert! The kids show it :-)!!
LikeLike
Thanks Eftychia! The kids definitely showed it – they were covered in whipped topping (and loving it!). 🙂
LikeLike
THat looks about as delicious as it can get!! – your kids look SO adorable and like they are loving that pie!
Mary
LikeLike
Miss A’s favorite part was the whipped topping squirted directly into her mouth. She thought that was a hoot! I asked her if she liked her pie. She gave an assertive, “YES! It tastes like sugar!” LOL. Right up her alley.
LikeLike
Wow! This is so simple, and I bet it’s really yummy! The look on your kids’ faces is priceless. I can tell they totally loved it!
LikeLike
It’s funny before we made it I figured making a Key lime pie was going to be a challenge. I’ve just always been so impressed by them in restaurants. I had no idea it was this easy. I’m sure we’ll be making it again. And yep, the kids loved it. It was a lot of fun with them. 🙂
LikeLike
Looks fantastic. Love the almond crust. I buy rye flour and that works great with fruit desserts too, when added into the regular flour! Thanks for sharing, and stopping by with comment love 🙂
Aimee
LikeLike
That sounds good too. I’m going to have to try out the rye flour. I can’t believe the number of flours out there. Cooking is so much fun! 🙂 Thanks for stopping by Aimee.
LikeLike
I forgot to mention how adorable your son is licking the cream off of his hand!lol Don’t tell anyone but I still do that! Hee, hee, hee!
LikeLike
LOL! We all had fun with that – a few squirts in the mouth, on the nose, a beard for Mr. N. It was good stuff. It was just so darned hot outside that it was melting really, really fast. 🙂
LikeLike
I love key lime pie! Yes, I just started to experiment too with almond flour for baking pie crust or baked goods. It’s a great gluten free alternative and great source of fiber, protien, healthy fats and minerals too!
Now I want to go to FL just to eat a pie! Though maybe next month we’ll do a road trip to visit my mother-in-law!
LikeLike
A road trip sounds like a blast! I can’t wait to leave on ours this summer. So ready. I’ve never road tripped to FL before, but always wanted to. Hubby’s parents have a place down there and I really want to get Miss A down there to a beach. She would just love it. I was a little nervous about the almond crust since I’ve never had one before and wasn’t sure it would match the Key lime, but it was delicious! And it is holding up really well in the fridge.
LikeLike
Oh that looks so good! Wow, I wish I was there now not for the beach but for that pie! I saw in a mag recently a little food trucks take on key lime pie. They made it just as usual, froze it with popsicle sticks so they could then cut in into bars and dip in chocolate. A chocolate covered key lime pie Popsicle! Genius!
LikeLike
Oh frozen in popsicles! I’m all about the frozen treats these days. The melting richness. Heaven. 🙂 That sounds delicious and what a great idea! Thanks again for the headband! I’m loving it. 🙂
LikeLike
Jacksonville jam cake! What key lime pie? No…. OK, this looks wonderful. Key Lime Pie does always make me think of Dexter. I love the almond crust. And do I get brownie points for knowing about key limes? Ha, I’ve never used them though.
LikeLike
LOL! And you can get your brownie points just for being you. 😉 We didn’t actually use Key limes in this one, but used a key lime juice instead. We did cook with Key limes in one of our first posts when we were covering Mexico. We made a Key lime chicken. They were yummy little things!
LikeLike
I have been meaning to make that pie forever!
yours looks amazing and I love the almond crust too!
LikeLike
It’s such an easy one! It’s a good one for a busy day when you need a fast dessert. The only time consuming part is the chilling. Other than that – super easy.
LikeLike
That almond crust looks delicious! I’ve always been curious about “key lime pie”… and having just looked it up on Wikipedia… holy crap, I just found out that “Key lime” is an actual thing… an actual fruit? Damn do I feel dumb now – I’ve never seen such a thing on sale before? Looks delicious though! Perhaps one day I can seek one out and make one myself.
LikeLike
LOL. Don’t feel dumb…there are so many foods I’ve never heard of and am discovering. For this pie you only need the juice which you can either do fresh from key limes (which are hard to find) or with key lime juice which is what we used this time. 🙂
LikeLike
I want to make this so bad – but seriously, I don’t think it’s possible to get key limes in Europe… I’ve *never* seen them. Could I substitute, say, limes and lemons or something… or is the taste very different?
LikeLike
I saw a cooking show on tv the other day and they substituted regular limes and supposedly it worked just fine. I’ve never tried it, but then again this is my first Key lime pie. I can’t imagine it would be all that different…
LikeLike
Great idea to use an almond crust! I bet it would give a nice flavor too. I see that you bought the already ground almond meal…next time I’m going to do that instead of grinding my own! I love anything lime and I love the pictures. Very cute!
LikeLike
You know I was going to use the almonds that I have, but then I happened upon the already ground stuff in the grocery store. I’m so glad I did – made this dessert soooooo easy. 🙂
LikeLike